In what could be seen as a metaphor for the broader frustrations of life in the Middle East, Rosemary Mahoney's
book may be titled Down the Nile, Alone in a Fisherman's Skiff, but it is more about the problems she has
achieving her goal of rowing down the Nile than the trip itself.
Most of the barriers and frustrations stem from her being a foreigner and a woman. Women just don't do things
like row, much less on their own in an Egypt where the native women are still largely hidden away behind robes
and doors. While foreign women, even savvy travelers such as Mahoney, are subject to a continual barrage of
intimate, often crude attentions. These preconceptions about women make it nearly impossible for the locals to
accept her, or her plans, seriously enough for necessary interactions, such as selling her a boat to row. To buy
one, she has to resort to subterfuge; such as pretending it is a gift for her (non-existent) husband.
And then there are the broader cultural divides. The whole idea of such a trip, based in rowing for pleasure,
is completely foreign to the Egyptians, who simply cannot understand it enough to co-operate in helping her get
what she needs, regardless of gender. Rowing is for work, not pleasure. Surely what she really wants is to have
them take her down the river in comfort in one of their boats (helping them earn their living, of course).
Eventually though, Rosemary has the good fortune to meet an unusual Egyptian boat-owner - a bit of a square
peg himself - who is honest, caring of her and interested in her as a person without it being just an act to get
sex. Her idea of rowing down the Nile on her own is just as foreign to him, but he invites her to take solo day
trip rows in his rowboat and he's willing to at least consider the larger plan. Ultimately he offers the only
version of it he sees as possible - she will row, but he will follow in his charter boat with a female friend of
hers, to safeguard her from harm. Rosemary accepts, but doesn't give up on her larger dream.
Rosemary is a beautifully observant, clear eyed traveling companion, who not only brings to life the Egypt
around her and her own experience of it, but does so realistically and as much on its own terms as an outsider
can. She writes with grace and empathy, not always agreeing with what she finds, but attempting to at least
understand it rather than judging blindly. Her own vision and experience is compared and contrasted throughout
the book with the experiences of travelers there before her, primarily Flaubert and Florence Nightingale, with
the result offering a depth most travelogues lack. To use her own quote from Flaubert, reflecting at the end of
her trip: "Travel never makes one cheerful. But it makes one thoughtful. It washes one's eyes and clears away
the dust." Highly recommended.