Cynthia DeFelice has created a memorable character in Allie. Allie is resourceful and a compassionate protagonist. She uses her deductive reasoning to discover Belle’s secret, but also takes chances at the end that makes for an unconventional climax. The most unusual character of this story is L. J. DeFelice introduces him as a surly uncaring individual, but develops his character into a surprising ally for Allie.

This is a good book to introduce students to the conventions of a mystery and building the story from the inception to the climax and conclusion. The descriptions are good and solid and lend themselves to use as a teaching tool. The best part of this book for me was the development of the major characters. Although L. J. is pivotal as an unknown, DeFelice brings him to life, makes him human and draws you into his life. This book does not leave you hanging, but it does mention DeFelice’s other mysteries starring Allie. If your child does not have much experience in reading mysteries, this is a good one to start with or perhaps The Ghost of Fossil Glen, the first book in the series or The Ghost and Mrs. Hobbs, the second.