Another Review at MyShelf.Com


The Girl From The Savoy
Hazel Gaynor

William Morrow
June 7, 2016/ ISBN 9780062403476
Historical / Fiction / Romance / 1923 / England

Reviewed by Elise Cooper


The Girl From The Savoy by Hazel Gaynor is a fascinating historical novel that touches on intense and compelling themes where dreams really do come true. Readers will take the adventurous journey with the main characters as they struggle with love, hope, loss, and healing.

This rags to riches story has Dorothy “Dolly” Lane struggling to overcome the low-life career of being a chambermaid, someone invisible to the upper class, while striving to become a renowned star of the London stage. Many readers might be reminded of the musical My Fair Lady based on the play Pygmalion. The storyline has Dorothy taken in by Loretta May, a famous actress who has a rebellious streak and lives as she likes. She hopes to teach Dorothy how to fit into upper society and become her protégé. But the story also has Loretta, the daughter of an Earl, falling in love and marrying a soldier, a commoner without a title.

Because she was inspired by this era Gaynor wanted to write about “social change and how the war affected this new decade. Women’s roles changed dramatically. The Great War opened their eyes to a new way of life when they entered the work force. For many it became impossible to return to a life in domestic service after the relative freedoms of factory or office work. The war also challenged the accepted social norms for young ladies. Many volunteered as nurses or had to manage without their husbands and sons, so that they became more independent, including fighting for the vote. I wanted to write strong women who were not victims and were in charge of their own identity. They are not needy of a man to take care of them.”

Set shortly after the end of WWI, this novel is told by three narrators in the first person, with each perspective offering some of the historical past. Through Dolly readers can explore the class system and the rise of women’s independence; Loretta and her brother Perry explore the Jazz Age; and Teddy Cooper, Dolly’s fiancé, is a solider whose life is changed by the war as he suffers from shell shock. It is through Teddy that readers understand how WWI loomed large over everyone and everything.

All the characters are fascinating and the many interesting secondary ones also influenced the story including the Savoy Hotel. Through the descriptions and events within the hotel it becomes clear that it takes on a personality of its own, almost speaking to the characters. For some it becomes a place of security, almost like returning to a long lost friend.

Many times people speak of hearing cracks and creaks within houses. Gaynor through her research found “people in the book and in the real world talk about it as a living, breathing character. It is a place where things were happening, where people came and went, with lots of interesting drama.”

It appears that the hotel reacts to the issues the characters face including their sense of loss and how they are haunted by those memories. Teddy has amnesia and lost the life he once knew. Reflected in this quote by Dolly are her feelings, “My heart was broken, my dreams were shattered, my hopes were bruised. Without ever stepping onto a battlefield, I too was wounded… In many ways Teddy did not come back at all.” Loretta lost her newlywed husband during the war, and Perry, the musical composer brother, lost his edge, preferring to be a follower than a leader, after being part of a firing squad that killed his best friend.

Gaynor noted, “There was this loss of innocence. Remember the famous line as soldiers went off to war, ‘It will be over by Christmas.’ The families left behind the lost years together. Many waited four years for loved ones to come home, and physically they might have, but the person once known, no longer existed. The lost years created a period of separation that placed an emotional strain on the loved ones. Typically history does not write about the women left behind on the home front, which is why I wrote the backstory of Dolly. Many were haunted by the loss of the life they had hoped to have. Unfortunately, people did not talk about how they felt. Instead, having to endure a stiff upper lip and a get on with it attitude.”

If The Girl From The Savoy is the first book read by Gaynor it will not be the last. She uses the backdrop of World War I to create a riveting and gripping plot with characters that will pull the reader immediately into the story. Not only will people learn about the history of the 1920s, but will feel they are along for the ride with the very well developed characters.

Reviews of other titles by this Author

The Girl From the Savoy
The Girl Who Came Home
The Cottingley Secret
Last Christmas in Paris - w/ Heather Webb

The Lighthouse Keepers Daughter

Reviewed 2016