The audiobook contains irreverent swipes at Jewish history, culture, holidays, travel, dining, hygiene, mothers, and other stereotypes. In addition to crafting the humor, which usually hits its mark, the authors obviously did extensive research in gathering information (or else paid really close attention during Hebrew school). Some of the material is raunchier than necessary and perpetuates unkind images of Jews, but overall Jewtopia offers an entertaining and comprehensive look at all things Jewish. Especially funny were their bits on Moses in the desert and grooming tips for "manscaping."

The audiobook differs from the hardback book which differs from the play, which inspired both. The audiobook relies heavily on the performances of Fogel and Wolfson, in addition to several characters portrayed by Tohn. Many of the characters are designed to annoy (and they certainly do), and throughout the work the authors appear uncomfortably self-aware of their inability to easily transition the material into different formats. A fast, funny, frolic through Jewtopia is just what the (Jewish) doctor ordered.