Another Review at MyShelf.Com

Murder in the Queen's Armes
Gideon Oliver Mysteries

by Aaron Elkins



      The "skeleton detective" Gideon Oliver is back, this time on his honeymoon in England. They are staying at an inn in Dorchester, a town famous for its large number of prehistoric sites. While in the local museum Gideon is horrified to find out that a well-known skull - 30,000 years old - has been stolen from its case. Simultaneously, he hears that an old college friend is digging nearby looking for Bronze Age remains and pays a call. But Nate Marcus has a strange theory about the people of this period that has surely been long since disproved, so why does he still insist that it is groundbreaking stuff? Soon after, the body of one of his students is found and Gideon's honeymoon turns into the inevitable battle of wits against a murderer.

This was originally published back in 1985, and is the third in the series. Having an anthropologist solve cases and come up with Sherlock Holmes style deductions based on bone fragments is an original idea, and the sort of thing that seems set for a lot of mileage. To date, Gideon has got his teeth into quite a variety of cases including a Cold War spy story and a more bizarre and effective story involving a rain forest and a lost tribe. Now he is in England with all that entails - unfortunately what it does entail are some patronizing remarks about the country and some unnecessarily aired views. Lyme Regis for example is "vaguely unsatisfying" and the views are "tame". This is, in my opinion, not a book for Brits. The plot is unusual, but could do with fleshing out a bit and being less linear. This is a thin book, but there is not enough in it to avoid a sag in the middle when nothing new is introduced and old ground gone over and over. If you loved these books when they were fresh, new and different back in the 1980s then surely this reprint is great nostalgia, but I wondered why this rather dated series has been reissued as frankly it hasn't stood the test of time very well.

The Book

Berkley Prime Crime (Penguin Group)
October 2005
Paperback
0425206386
Crime - Contemporary, Dorset, UK
More at Amazon.com
Excerpt
NOTE:

The Reviewer

Rachel A Hyde
Reviewed 2005
NOTE:
© 2005 MyShelf.com